The Concept Of Financial Innovation And Diversification Finance Essay

Diversification is a scheme used by houses to spread out their operations by adding markets, merchandises, services, or phases of production to the bing concern. The purpose of variegation is to let a company come ining lines of concern that are different from their normal operations.

Diversification normally refered as “ come ining new market with new merchandises ” as per Ansoff ( 1957,1958 ) . However, Rumelt ( 1974 ) relates variegation scheme as a houses “ committedness to diverseness per Se, together with the strengths, accomplishments or aim that span this diverseness, shown by the manner in which concern activities are related to one another ‘ . In an bureau point of position, directors diversify chiefly through acquisition and this will increase their compensation, occupation security, or span of control ( Amihud and lev ( 1981 ) ; Born, Eisenbeis, and Harn ‘s ( 1988 ) ) . In an efficiency point of position, variegation will let houses to cut down specific hazard by keeping a wider assortment of assets and services. ( Saunders, Strock, and Travlos ( 1998 ) ) . Manganelli S. and Popov A. ( 2010 ) defines variegation as the set of allotments of sum end product across sectors which minimise the economic system ‘s long term volatility for a given degree of long term growing.

However, the reading of this empirical determination has been that “ variegation destroys value. ” Among many other grounds discussed in the literature, Martin and Sayrak ( 2003 ) , this value devastation could be due to inefficient internal capital markets ( Stulz, ( 1990 ) ) or to act upon costs that arise as a consequence of internal power battles ( Rajan, Servaes, and Zingales ( 2000 ) ) .

2.1.2 Diversification in the Financial Sector

The most of import characteristic in the variegation scheme of houses in the fiscal sector is the ternary part of the commercial banking, investing banking and insurance concern, ( Insill Yi, 2005 ) . The latter besides developed the construct of universal banking which is defined as fiscal companies offering a broad scope of fiscal merchandises which includes ; sedimentations, loans, foreign exchange dealing, securities firm and issurance of bonds, insurances and plus direction among others.

The phenomenon of variegation can be considered as a natural development procedure of the fiscal sector and this can be reflected by the transmutation of the construction of these houses. Similarly, the Financial Services Modernization Act of 1999 ( FSM ) made proviso for beef uping the overall fiscal services sector by leting fiscal houses to diversify across industries within the fiscal sector.

2.1.3 Transformation in the fiscal sector sector

Since the mid 1990s immense alterations has been encountered in the fiscal services industry. The impact of, amongst other things, information engineering, deregulating and liberalization has changed and reshaped the fiscal landscape forever, ( Ruding H. O. 2002 ) . Apart from the conventional economic and population growing, Bankss and insurance houses now fight ferociously for market portion and resort to variegation to turn their portfolios.

It may besides be argued that the convergence in the fiscal sector can be considered as an illustration of variegation.

2.1.4 Drivers prima houses to diversify

Thomas Egan and Chong Ng ( 1992 ) stated that the retail fiscal services industry is confronting major alterations. That is, traditional retail fiscal services suppliers ‘ such as bank and security houses are prodded with new and alone techniques. The latter stated that domestic Bankss, traditional suppliers of fiscal services, have adopted new competitory schemes. The primary aim is to advance growing. This is normally achieved by increasing market portion, seeking for new gross watercourses by come ining into new markets and acquisitions or through joint ventures, at the same time cut downing their operating costs and besides diversify hazards.

This transmutation is chiefly driven by technological invention ; besides a deregulating of fiscal services at national degree to open to international degree competition. Equally, of import alteration takes topographic point in corporate behaviour, such as turning disintermediation and increased accent on stockholder value.

Hence, the fiscal services industry is quickly reshaping itself so as ‘to expression for new chances for growing outside conventional concern lines. ‘ Some of the most of import drivers taking the fiscal services industry to diversify and follow new schemes are mentioned below.

Technological inventions have fostered an extended enlargement of the fiscal sector worldwide since the last decennary. Barth et Al. ( 2004 ) stated that this has lead to the economic growing of this sector and hence provide greater efficiency in foreign banking markets, bettering the handiness of foreign persons and houses to fiscal goods and services, and supplying foreign counties greater entree to international capital.similarly, Petersenand Rajan ( 2002 ) , considers that Competition has intensified with the coming of new engineering since more houses are come ining the traditional market infinite. Hence, as per Stewart ( 2000 ) and Egan et Al ( 1992 ) , to be able to get by with the dynamic fiscal universe, houses need to put massively in new engineering like, E-banking, samarium banking, automated teller machines among other to stay competitory.

Globalization has been the cant of economic sciences today ( Hudson G. ) . This has lead to the liberalisation of the planetary market and more flexible ordinance has been established to advance the motion of houses worldwide. As stated by Ansoff ( 1979 ) , these houses have been able to supply a wider scope of merchandises and services and will be able to further diversify their concern activity. As a effect, houses have been more competitory and efficient ( Aarcis, 1980 ) . However, due to the recent fiscal crisis, new legal model and control will be set up to supervise the dealing happening in the fiscal sector overall.

2.1.5 Types of variegation

When the new venture is strategically related to the bing lines of concern, it is called homocentric variegation. Conglomerate variegation occurs when there is no common yarn of strategic tantrum or relationship between the new and old lines of concern ; the new and old concerns are unrelated.

Five types of variegation:






Related and unrelated variegation

Refering the conditions under which variegation is likely to make value, confusion has promoted empirical enquiry of particulars signifiers of variegation. For illustration, assorted bookmans such as Rumelt ( 1982 ) ; Beths and Mahajain ( 1985 ) ; Maskides and Willamsons ( 1994 ) ; Robins and Wiorsema ( 1995 ) ; Palich, Cardinal and Miller ( 2000 ) found that more value is created by related variegation instead than unrelated variegation.

However, even if, on norm related variegation may be making more value than unrelated variegation, some houses may really be destructing value from related variegation while others are making value from unrelated variegation. Similarly, Acemoglu and Zilibotti ( 1997 ) , claim that variegation occurs endogenously as a consequence of the agents ‘ determinations to put in a scope of amiss correlated undertakings. Hence, on this footing every bit good, it becomes hard to bring forth from mean effects.

To reason, like many phenomena in the field of scheme, variegation makes a different consequence on each and every house depending on the house ‘s alone place, resources and capablenesss.

2.1.6 Reasons for variegation

Diversification schemes to heighten or increase the strategic fight of the overall organisation may be implemented by companies. The value of the concern addition when they are successful. Both related and unrelated variegation can make value if the schemes enable the company ‘s mix of concern to increase grosss and/or lessening costs when their several business-level schemes are implemented.

To obtain market power, comparative to their rivals, companies may besides implement a variegation scheme, which is either value impersonal, or consequences in their devaluation. This variegation may neutralize a rival ‘s market power or cut down director ‘s employment hazard ( that is, when a dominant-business company fails every bit compared to this hazard when a individual concern fails but is lone portion of a diversified company, there is the hazard of the CEO being unemployed ) or to increase managerial compensation because variegation is positively related to company size and compensation.

Corporate schemes has therefore, been found to spread out range of operations through variegation into new concerns. Assuming of an efficient market, there is yet no apparent rational for the company to get another, peculiarly less efficient or unrelated concern.

2.1.7 Advantages of Diversification scheme

Economies of graduated table and range ( synergism ) through activity-sharing and reassign nucleus competences ( Chandler 1977 ; Teece 1982 ; Berlin 1999 )

Unifying two companies bring forthing similar merchandises allow a house to canvass production and achieving a lower operating cost. The company may come from reduced operating expense or the ability to hold a larger production sum over lower ( consolidated ) fixed costs. Differential direction capablenesss may besides take topographic point such that a less efficient house may be acquired by a more expeditiously managed one to convey a better direction to the concern. Through pooled fiscal resources or merely pooled hazard, efficiencies may besides be gained.

Market power motivations ( related variegation ) by perpendicular integrating or blocking rivals through multipoint competition ( Montgomery 1994 )

A house ‘s market portion can be increased by amalgamations and acquisitions when both houses are in the same concern. However, market portion does non needfully interpret to higher net incomes or greater value for proprietors unless sit well reduces market competition. Then, the job is the chance of anti-trust action by the Justice Department.

Net income stableness

Variations in corporate net incomes can be reduced by the acquisition of the new concern by spread outing the corporation ‘s lines of concern. This typically occurs when gross revenues of the nucleus concern are seasonal or cylindrical. For case, husbandmans guarantee year-around income from graduated table of merchandises by seting a spring harvest and a autumn harvest.

Diversification besides makes sense when the nucleus merchandise market is unsure. Hence, variegation schemes besides apply to general instances of distributing market hazards. This is to state: adding merchandises to bing lines of concern can be considered as being correspondent to an investor puting in multiple stocks to ‘spread the hazards ‘ .

Fiscal theoreticians argue that the corporation due to the impact of diversified concern portfolios has replaced the traditional function of the investor in picking victors and also-rans in the industry investings for corporations. This has given rise to the bureau job: why should investors protect direction from market hazards by support of the firm-the hazard minimisation benefit accrues to the director in footings of occupation security.

Improve fiscal performance-financial economic systems motivations to better efficiency of capital allotment through an internal capital or by destructing the portfolio of concern

Large houses can put the hard currency generated in other ventures. The steadfast acts as a banker of an internal capital market. Furthermore, nucleus concern can prolong itself on its money devising ventures, utilizing this hard currency flow to bring forth extra net incomes in new ventures.


Some governments cite variegation as being the chief ground for growing. Contrary to impersonal growing ( in which a longer period is required for planning, developing and implementing a new undertaking ) , an acquisition or amalgamation can be achieved rather rapidly with staff, engineering, systems and experience instantly available. Merger and acquisition is besides a manner to increase growing.

2.1.8 Diversification in the Banking sector

The twenty-first century has been a complete transmutation in the banking system. The major Bankss in the banking industry has become more complex and they offer a wider assortment of merchandises and services to international markets and control one million millions of dollars in hard currency and assets. Bing implemented by the latest engineering, Bankss are now looking for new chances in new concern, to develop personalize service to clients, to implement advanced schemes and to capture new market chances. Furthermore, with the globalisation making more and more states, the fiscal sectors worldwide will be more diversified. Although, there has been two different type system, i.e. commercial and investing banking, since the recent decennary a convergence between the activities of the commercial and investing banking has been observed. This is once more chiefly due to the deregulating in the fiscal sector. Today, both type of banking establishments can vie to each other in the money market operations, private arrangements, undertakings, undertaking finance, bonds subventioning and fiscal consultative work.

Furthermore, in the new epoch of modernisation, banking industry has brought greater concern variegation. Some Bankss have entered into investings, underwriting of securities, portfolio direction and the insurance concerns. Hence, these alterations have made Bankss an even more competitory.

As stated by Rumelt, ( 1974 ) Banks adopt variegation move as a portion of growing scheme and they may take to spread out their busniess via diversifying geographically or/and via merchandise market variegation. That is by adding new merchandises and concern lines.

2.1.9 Diversification in the Insurance sector

Insurance companies can be considered as one of the major types of fiscal mediators. They collect premiums from investors and financess from the authorities. Previously insurance companies were merely runing in lone life, wellness and general insurance. However, with modernization and increasing competitions from other houses, they have to diversify into new Fieldss. Now they are engaged in pension strategies, common financess, plus direction etc.

In 2008, the worldwide insurance premiums were to hold increased to US $ 4,270bn: US $ 2,490 bn for life insurance premiums and US $ 1,779 bn for non-life. Since 1980, it was the first clip that premiums declined in existent footings: life decreased by 3.5 % while non-life fell by 0.8 % .

For both life and non-life insurance concern, Africa contributed to 1.3 % of the entire universe premium. Mauritius contributed 0.8 % to the African insurance market. Besides, being on the 84th rank worldwide, Mauritius contributed 0.01 % to the universe entire premium volumes.[ 1 ]

Vittas D. ( 2003 ) stated in study that if the insurance companies are to stay efficient, their chief challenges will lie in beef uping the effectual supervising and overhauling the legal and regulative model.

The Concept of Diversification and other variables

Diversification and Growth

G. J. Thomas considers variegation is a signifier of growing scheme which involves a important addition in public presentation aims like gross revenues or market portion beyond past degrees of public presentation. Bosworth et Al, 1997 stated that direction penchants may advance signifiers growing or other nonsubjective instead than profitableness, since variegation allows for faster growing than is possible by increasing market portion, or profiting from demand addition, in a individual market.

Diversification and hazard

Ines Kahloul and Slaheddine Hallara ( 2000 ) , stated that hazard and its constituent additions with degree of variegation. However disciplinarian ( 2006 ) considers that the construct of variegation is used to administer the hazard. Amihud and Lev, ( 1981 ) ; Wright and Al, ( 2007 ) besides consider that variegation is a mean for the decrease of hazard. As per Sethi J. and Bhatia N. ( 2007 ) there is a possibility of cut downing hazard though diversifying in cosmopolitan fiscal services.

Diversification and profitableness

Roger ( 2001 ) stated that more focussed houses are more profitable because low profitable houses diversify in hunt of higher net incomes. Furthermore, since some houses consider variegation as a agency to cut down hazard and they readily accept a lower border of net income.

Rumelt ( 1974 ) found that corporate profitableness differed significantly across groups of houses following different ‘strategies ‘ of variegation. Hence, the highest degrees of profitableness were houses holding a scheme of diversifying chiefly into those countries of the same line of concern.

Diversification and house ‘s value

Over the last two decennaries, empirical grounds published on the wealth effects of corporate variegation has created batch of divergency of sentiment. Before the mid 1980s, Jensen and Ruback, ( 1983 ) and Bradley, Desai, and Kim, ( 1988 ) , stated that diversifying acquisition was usually associated with a little positive impact on the stockholders wealth. More late in the twenty-first century, Billett and Mauer ( 2000a, B ) and Hadlock, Ryngaert, and Thomas ( 2001 ) supply grounds to propose that variegation may heighten steadfast value. However research workers like Lang and Stulz, ( 1994 ) ; Servaes, ( 1996 ) ; and Berger and Ofek, ( 1995 ) , ( 1999 ) , suggested that variegation may diminish stockholder wealth.

2.1.11 New diversifying chances in the fiscal sector

Scholtens and Wensveen ( 1999 ) province that ; for fiscal establishments to stay competitory in the international market, they need to implement their portfolio of merchandises and services and look for new fiscal inventions. The is chiefly due to the increasing competition encountered by the banking and insurance houses because of the outgrowth of non banking establishments like common financess, recognition brotherhood, shariah compliant establishments, and fiscal services houses etc.

Bancassurance and Assurfinance

Bancassurance is one of the major developments in the fiscal services sector since the recent few old ages. Banking and insurance house see bancassurance to be an attractive and profitable manner to supplement their existing activities.

Harmonizing to the Life Insurance Marketing and Research Association ‘s ( LIMRA ‘s ) insurance dictionary bancassurance can be define as “ the proviso of Life insurance services by Bankss and edifice societies ” . Similarly, ( Alan Leach, 2000 ) describes bancassurance as “ the engagement of Bankss, nest eggs Bankss and edifice societies in the fabrication, selling or distribution of insurance merchandises ” . Harmonizing to the study of the Munich Re Group on Bancassurance, it is defined as follows “ Bancassurance is the proviso of insurance and banking merchandises and services through a common distribution channel and/or to the same client base. ”

The undermentioned grounds have made the success of Bancassurance:

Banks have used their bing mercantile establishments to sell insurance.

Promote one to one contact with client

Tailor made merchandises will be made available to clients at one-stop-shopping convenience.

Bancassurance is considered to be much more cost efficient compared to the traditional insurance merchandising.

However, Insurers has reacted positively to the outgrowth of bancassurance. They have accordingly strengthened and improved their bing distribution web. Furthermore, fiscal merchandises offered by insurance companies were upgraded. Consequently, they have come up with the construct of Assurfinance, whereby insurance companies have started trading in other fiscal merchandises apart from conventional insurance policy.

Islamic Finance

Since, the beginning of the millenary, we have witness a fast development in Islamic finance merchandises. Professional bankers and Shari’ah specializers have been breathlessly rushing to contrive new Islamic fiscal merchandises that mimic or replace every individual interest-based contract that comes in the conventional market in a rushing effort to make full in all spreads and fulfill every funding need that may be thought of ( Monzer Kahf 2006 ) .

The chief rules of Islamic finance include:

Prohibition of taking or having involvement ;

capital must hold a societal and ethical intent beyond pure, unregulated return ;

investings in concerns covering with points like ( intoxicant, gaming, drugs, etc ) that the Shari’ah considers improper are deemed unwanted and prohibited ;

a prohibition on minutess affecting masir that is, guess or gaming ; and

a prohibition on gharar, or uncertainness about the subject-matter and footings of contracts – this includes a prohibition on selling something that one does non have.

Khan and Ahmad ( 2003 ) argued that Islamic Bankss non merely confront the type of hazards that conventional Bankss face but they are besides confronted with “ new and alone hazards as a consequence of their alone plus and liability constructions. ” They besides stated that, this new type of hazards is an immediate result of their conformity with the Shari’ah demand and this nature of hazard which does non necessitate collateral of plus ( Errico and Farahbaksh,1998 ) are different from conventional Bankss hazard.

Pension financess

( Davis 1995a ) defines pension fund as signifiers of institutional investor, which collect and put financess contributed by patrons and donees to supply for the future pension entitlements of donees. Hence, pension fund provide an person the installation to do salvaging during their on the job life and to finance their ingestion demands in retirement, either by agencies of a ball amount or by proviso of an rente, while besides providing financess to end-users such as corporations, other families or authoritiess for investing or ingestion. Pension financess have encountered a positive growing since the new decennary in developed every bit good as developing states. Furthermore, pension financess have an of import indirect function to play in hiking the efficiency of the fiscal systems, by act uponing the construction of securities markets. As per ( Bodie 1990b, 1999 ) , pensions financess may move as establishments investors and can therefore do the usage of derived functions and other agencies of hazard control and may besides merchandise in fiscal invention merchandises to provide the demand of the populace.

Features of pension:

hazard pooling for little investors, supplying a better spread of hazard

a premium on variegation is obtained by both keeping a spread of domestic and international investing ;

Provides more liquidness, and hence for big and liquid capital markets, which trade criterion or ‘commoditised ‘ instruments ;

pension financess rely on public information instead than private, which links strongly to their desire for liquidness ;

2.2 Empirical Reappraisal

2.2.1 Relationship between Diversification and Firm Performance

Harmonizing to Palish and Al. ( 2000 ) , the subject of the diversification- public presentation relation is far from being exhausted. This is so, as each research worker has a different point of position about the construct of variegation.

Kahloul and Hallara ( 2000 ) carried out a survey between the relationship between the degree of variegation and the steadfast public presentation. Longitudinal information of sample of 69 houses were used to analyze the public presentation of the company. Return on Assetss ( ROA ) was the placeholder to entree the degree of public presentation of the houses and GROWTH was the explanatory factor for steadfast public presentation. Consequently, a non additive relationship was obtained and ( Kahloul and Haallara 2000 ) have suggested an intermediary scheme between variegation and specialisation.

Similarly, Rogers ( 2001 ) , investigate the function of variegation on house public presentation, and happen out that in instance where there is intense competition, no relationship can be expected variegation and public presentation.

Pandya and Rao ( 1998 ) conducted a survey on the relationship between house variegation and its public presentation. The consequence obtain indicated that on mean extremely diversified houses tend to execute better every bit compared to undiversified houses on the hazard and return. The variables used to measure the house and managerial public presentation are as follows ; ROE, ROI, ROA, ROC and ROS.

The ground for utilizing these steps is to measure managerial public presentation and how good is a house ‘s direction utilizing the assets to bring forth accounting returns on investing, assets or gross revenues. Since accounting conventions make these variables undependable, fiscal economic experts prefer to utilize market returns or discounted hard currency flows as steps of public presentation. Hence, the following variable can be used.

Tax return on equity ( ROE ) is usually used in judging top direction public presentation, and for doing executive compensation determinations. It is besides used to cipher the mean return on equity ( AROE ) across houses.

ROE ( return on Equity ) =net income divided /stockholders equity.

ROA ( Return on plus ) is the most often used public presentation step in old surveies.

ROA= net income / divided by the book value of entire assets.

Some surveies suggest that diversifying in related merchandise will bring forth higher returns as compared to unrelated merchandise and besides stated that less diversified houses perform better than extremely diversified houses ( Christensen and Montgomery 1981, Keats 1990, Michel and Shaked 1984, Rumelt 1974, 1982, 1986 ) .

Similarly, apart from variegation types and the industry construction, Simmonds ( 1990 ) , Lamont and Anderson ( 1985 ) have found those related diversified houses perform better than unrelated diversified houses.

However some claims that the economic systems in incorporating operations and nucleus accomplishments obtained in related variegation outweigh the costs of internal capital markets and the smaller discrepancies in gross revenues grosss generated by unrelated variegation ( Datta, Rajagopolan and Rasheed 1991 ) . Prahalad and Bettis ( 1986 ) agreed that related scheme is better than unrelated, and they stated that the penetration and the vision of the top directors in taking the right scheme is derteminent.

Rumelt P. ( 1982 ) studied the consequence of variegation scheme and profitableness. The latter selected a mark population of 273 of houses from 1949 to 1974. The houses degree of variegation was evaluated as follows:

Single concern

Dominant perpendicular

Dominant constrained

Dominant Linked- unrelated

Related constrained

Related linked

Unrelated concern

They accordingly noted that, along the old ages, the individual concern house encountered a steady diminution along the old ages but a rapid growing in the related and unrelated concern classs. However, unrelated concern house growing was haltered during the period since 1960s. Furthermore, the variable used to mensurate profitableness was return on invested capital.

Where, Y is net income after revenue enhancements ( but before preferable dividends.

I, Interest disbursal on long term debt

K, amount of the book values of proprietor ‘s equity and long term debt