English Language Essays – English Second Language

English Second Language

The Benefits of and Drawbacks of Allowing English as Second Language Programs In Elementary Education


There are 1000s of immigrant kids throughout the United States enrolled in ESL ( English as Second Language ) plans throughout 100s of simple schools. ESL plans cover content countries like math, scientific discipline, and societal surveies. The ends of ESL plans are to develop a child’s societal linguistic communication, academic linguistic communication, and sociocultural cognition.

While many say that ESL plans help pupils to boom, some surveies have shown that ESL pupils are non being adequately taught and do non run into set criterions ( Gomez, 2007 ) . By analyzing what is required by the province, instructors, and pupils in ESL plans, a better apprehension of the benefits and drawbacks of holding these ESL plans in simple schools will be determined, along with whether or non these plans should be available to kids.

The issue of ESL plans in simple schools is of import to look at because of the many kids enrolled in these plans. They are the 1s that are instantly impacted from holding these classs. Many policy shapers, community leaders, and even Congress have agreed that ESL plans are in demand of a alteration. Congress has recognized the fact that there are excessively few ESL plans.

They besides agree that the 1s in topographic point are overbooked. Students may hold to wait extended periods of clip before being enrolled in these plans ( Tucker, 2007 ) . A thorough probe demands to be conducted to find whether or non English as Second Language plans are good or damaging to immigrate kids in the United States.

The best manner for a thorough probe to be to the full conducted is by utilizing an interdisciplinary attack. This issue meets the standards needed for an interdisciplinary attack to be conducted ( Repko, 2005 ) . The topic of ESL plans is complex, which means that it has countries of involvement in many different Fieldss. This issue besides shows involvement from more than two subjects.

This subject can non be solved by a exclusive subject ; it needs to be evaluated from many different countries to be to the full understood. Stressing on entirely one subject would restrict the information needed to work out this subject. This issue is besides wide. Finally, ESL plans in simple schools address a social job or demand.

There has been a batch of research conducted to find whether or non ESL plans are good or more detrimental to kids. The research conducted has had to cover with many different subjects. The subjects involved with this issue refering to ESL plans are Spanish, English, Communications, and Sociology. The subjects that are of high importance areSpanish,English, andsociology.

Both of the subjects of Spanish and English are of import to this probe on ESL plans because they are the primary signifiers of communicating. The survey of each linguistic communication besides reveals the cultural differences represented by the linguistic communications. Spanish is the primary NL ( Native Language ) for most Latino immigrant pupils. This is the most popular primary linguistic communication that is being spoken among pupils. English is chiefly the 2nd linguistic communication among Latino immigrant pupils ( Calderon, Hertz-Lazarowitz, & A ; Slavin, 1998 ) .

This subject deals with a batch of hot button issues throughout the full United States. There are a big figure of people who want to see English be the exclusive beginning of communicating for learning. By implementing this linguistic communication, the demand for ESL plans would be eradicated. The subject of sociology trades with the single pupil themselves. This subject looks at the effects on the pupil every bit good as the households of those pupils in ESL plans. Sociology besides looks at the social effects of leting some pupils to tae ESL classs, while others are being taught entirely English ( Zhou, 1997 ) .

The method of research that will be conducted for this paper will be a thorough literature reappraisal of peer-reviewed beginnings from the subjects Spanish, English, and sociology. The intent of this paper is to find whether or non ESL plans are good or more detrimental to kids in simple schools. This is an of import issue because of the big figure of kids that are involved in these classs. This paper will besides concentrate on three subjects to reply the subject: Spanish, English, and sociology.


English as Second Language classs were originally intended for immigrant grownups. Teaching immigrant kids English was non viewed as a top precedence. English as Second Language classs have grounds of being linked to British intercultural control.

The instruction of English became of import because of it being the direct reply to a political duty. English was viewed as a immense factor for the substructure that was needed for the spread of British neocolonial control ( Auerbach, 1993 ) . By the 19Thursdaycentury, public schools were leting bilingual instruction, every bit long as it was in understanding with the political power of cultural groups.

Towards the terminal of the 19Thursdaycentury, bilingual instruction was worsening. This diminution was caused by the rise of nativism and antiforeign political mentality distributing throughout the state ( Auerbach, 1993 ) .

Theodore Roosevelt said, “Any adult male who comes here must adopt…the native lingua of our people…It would be a crime…to perpetuate differences in linguistic communication in this country” ( Mitchell, 2005, pg.253 ) . The sentiments of nativism are being felt to this twenty-four hours. The United States still has a big per centum of its population that wants no foreign influence in any of import facet of their life, including what is being taught in schools. For this paper, merely these types of external factors will be discussed.

These factors include the influence of the culture/society, the household, the instruction degree required to be achieved by the pupils in the province of Texas in simple schools, and the instruction required to be taught by the province of Texas in simple schools.

Although English was being taught throughout the 18Thursdaycentury, this paper will concentrate on the 19Thursdayand 20Thursdaycentury.By World War I, there was a big addition in the figure of immigrants coming into the United States. Immigrants were get downing to hold a bigger function in the labour motion. This was an added cause for the rise of xenophobic attitudes in the early 20Thursdaycentury.

The jobs that America was confronting, politically and economically, were blamed on “foreign influence” . The Americanization motion was get downing to derive a strong influence because of these jobs ( Auerbach, 1993 ) .The Americanization motion was started during the first one-fourth of the twentieth century.

The immigrants in the United States were persuaded to conform to American address, ideals, traditions, and ways of life. Fear and intuition of the immigrants gave motive to the motion. Social workers and caputs of concerns began to make organisations to assist raise the life conditions that immigrants were confronting.

These organisations were formed at the municipal, province, and federal degree to have assistance to assist absorb the immigrants into American imposts. World War I merely helped to beef up the motion.

The Federal Bureau of Education ( FBN ) and the Federal Bureau of Naturalization ( FBN ) joined the motion. Rallies, loyal naturalisation proceedings, and expansive Fourth of July jubilations were typical throughout the motion.

When the United States entered World War I, Americanization was made an official portion of the war attempt. Some provinces passed statute law supplying for the instruction and Americanization of immigrants. By 1921, every province that had a big immigrant population had provided instruction installations for the immigrants ( Columbia Encyclopedia, 2007 ) .

ESL classs were used to advance fidelity to America, every bit good as to a person’s job.English was connected with holding nationalism. When you spoke proper English, you were considered a good American. Children, during this same period of Americanization, were encouraged to hold linguistic communication trueness through curses they were required to memorise and right pronounce. For illustration, I love the United States of America. I love my country’s flag. I love my country’s linguistic communication. I promise:

1. That I will non disgrace my country’s address by go forthing off the last syllables of words.

2. That I will state a good American “yes” and “no” in topographic point of an Indian oink “um-hum” and “nup-um” or a foreign “ya” or “yeh” and “nope” . ( Robbins, 1918, as cited in Baron, 1990, as cited in Auerbach, 1993, pg. 13 )

During the first portion of the twentieth century, ESL classs and direction were a direct consequence of the Americanization motion. During this period of clip, the learning method of utilizing unwritten English was used. This meant that the usage of a student’s native linguistic communication ( NL ) was no longer accepted, and English merely in ESL classs began ( Auerbach, 1993 ) .

During this period when English merely was being used, the immigrant kids were expected to alter their names or the pronunciation of their names. This was done to assist the school decision makers easy pronounce their names. The civilizations of the immigrant kids were non wholly accepted in the schools at that clip either.

Their native linguistic communication and civilizations were non taken into consideration for test. As a consequence, a batch of pupils were deemed as mentally challenged because of the failure rate of their tests ( Christian, 1976, as cited in Simoes, 1976, as cited in Retzak, 2003 ) .

During the early 1920’s, grownup ESL classs were started to assist learn practical English for mundane life. These classs included learning the immigrants how to open bank histories, ask for waies, travel to sophisticate visits, and do purchases. Teachers were warned non to let coteries in the schoolroom that would halt the Americanization procedure. In the 1950’s and 1960’s, five basic rules were get downing to emerge.

First, English is taught better monolingually. Second, the English instructor should be a native talker. Third, the earlier English is taught, the better the consequences from the pupils are. Forth, the more English is taught, the better the consequences. Finally, if other linguistic communications ( NL ) are used excessively much, the criterions of English will drop ( Auerbach,
1993 ) .

As we have seen throughout the last several centuries, the issues and concerns with ESL instruction are ongoing. This of import subject still needs to be explained with the subjects of English, Spanish, and sociology. Two things need to be accomplished before this issue is to the full understood and answered.

Each subject needs to be separately evaluated and studied. By looking at each one separately, we can find how each subject answers the inquiry of ESL class benefits and drawbacks. In order for each subject to to the full explicate and demo the full image that ESL courses entail, the subjects need to be studied in a peculiar order.

For the intent of this paper, the subjects will be studied as follows: sociology, English, and Spanish. The subjects need to be studied in this order because, as mentioned earlier, sociology explains the conditions of society. This subject will besides explicate the demands that immigrant and American civilizations are confronting. Once all the societal demands are explained and studied, the subjects of English and Spanish can be examined.

Both of these subjects will hold similar justifications for their logical thinkings. Each one will demo how beneficial/damaging they would be as a linguistic communication in ESL schoolrooms. After going to the full educated in what each subject explains, the three will necessitate to be combined to happen one set of possible solutions. After being synthesized, the complete image will be clear and an reply will be apparent ( Repko, 2005 ) .



Gomez, E.Parents guide to the ESL criterions for Pre-K-12 pupils: Introduction and common

inquiries.Tesol.com. Retrieved November 28, 2007, from

hypertext transfer protocol: //www.Tesol.org/s_tesol/sec_document.asp? CID=662 & A ; DID=322 & A ; rcss=print & A ; print

Retzak, A. ( 2003 ) . Teacher allotment of bends to limited English proficiency pupils [ Abstract ].

University of Wisconsin-Stout.


Auerbach, E. ( 1993 ) . Reviewing English merely in the ESL schoolroom.TESOL Quarterly, 27( 1 ) ,

9-32. P

Calderon, M. , Hertz-Larowitz, R. , & A ; Slavin, R. ( 1998 ) . Effectss of bilingual incorporate reading

and composing on pupils doing the passage from Spanish to English reading.The

Elementary School Journal,99( 2 ) , 153-165. P

Mitchell, C. ( 2005 ) . English merely: the creative activity and Maintenance of an academic lower class.

Journal of Latinos and Education, 4 ( 4 ) , 253-270. P

Tucker, J. ( 2007, Jumping ) . Waiting times for ESL categories and the impact on English scholars.

National Civic Review, 96( 1 ) , 30-37. P


Columbia Encyclopedia. ( 2007 ) .Americanisation.Columbia University Press. Retrieved

March 1, 2008, from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.bartleby.com/65/am/Amer-izatn.html

Zhou, M. ( 1997 ) . Turning up American: The challenge facing immigrant kids and the

kids of immigrants.Annual Review of Sociology, 23( 1 ) , 63. P

Extra Beginnings

Repko, A. ( 2005 ) .Interdisciplinary pattern: A pupil usher to research and authorship. Boston,

Ma: Pearson.