A Comparison Of Canadian And Us Banking Systems Finance Essay


This paper will concentrate on the Canadian banking system and the US banking system. It will put particular accent on Differences between the fiscal system of both the states and its banking ordinance.

Banks today offer a wider scope of merchandises and services than of all time before, and present them faster and more expeditiously. But banking ‘s cardinal map remains as it has ever been. Banks help in roll uping excess financess ( sedimentations and investings ) to work by imparting to people to purchase places and autos, to get down and spread out concerns, to set their kids through college, and for infinite other intents. Banks today forms the anchor of our state ‘s economic system. For 10s of 1000000s of people across the whole universe, Bankss are the first pick for salvaging, adoption, and puting.

Though the operation of Bankss remains more or less the same across all states but there are bound to be some differences. Similarly Canada and US being neighbours ‘ portion many similarities and unsimilarities in their banking system which would be discussed in this paper in front.

Definition – Bank and Banking System

An Institution which is regularized by the authorities to cover in exchange of money by imparting to and having money from the general populace and assorted establishments It has many instruments through which it does its premier map which is covering with money affairs. Few illustrations of these instruments are supplying loans, clip and money sedimentations, puting in securities, for which it changes involvement. And finally the bank makes net income through the difference in the involvement rate charged and paid.

Servicess offered by Bankss

Accepting sedimentations from the general populace in the signifier of checking and salvaging history. For this the Bankss provide with some sum of involvement to the populace.

It Lends money to companies and single in the signifier of short term and long term loans. For this the Bankss alterations involvement from the borrower.

Cashing cheque. A cheque is an instrument which instructs a fiscal establishment to pay a specific sum of hard currency to a specific individual on a specific day of the month.

Publishing plastic money. Plastic money is of many types such as ATM cards, debit cards, recognition cards.

Banks besides provides with cabinet installations for hive awaying valuables.

Banking in Canada

In today ‘s clip Banking is the back bone of any economic system. Similarly banking in Canada besides forms a really of import portion of the economic system.It is arguably the most efficient and the safest banking system in the whole universe. The two chief types of Bankss are cardinal bank and commercial bank which are besides called the hired Bankss in Canada. The cardinal bank of Canada conducts of import responsibilities such as pecuniary policies which lends money to the commercial Bankss which in bends lends money to the general populace.

Brief history of banking in Canada

Bank of Montreal was formed in 1817 when banking in Canada began to migrate from abroad banking operation to a local banking system. Finally when other Bankss started to follow and began its concern and bit by bit attained blessing, it gave rise to unregulated banking. Until amendments in theA British North America ActA allowed federal and provincial authoritiess to get down to present their ain notes get downing in 1866, these establishments issue the local currency notes. Official Canadian currency took the signifier of the Canadian dollar in 1871, overruling the currency of single Bankss. Bank of Canada was formed in 1935 which was another important move for the banking in Canada.

In the yesteryear there were five basic principal groups on which Canadian fiscal system was based on: hired Bankss, trust and loan companies, the co-operative recognition motion, life insurance companies, and securities traders. The nucleus concern activities of these groups were characterized by the legal power under which they were incorporated and supervised which were federal and provincial or the combination of the both.

The federal authorities supervised and incorporated the hired Bankss, which were involved in commercial loaning. Their premier activity was that of supplying commercial loans and residential mortgage recognition.But in recent yesteryear and now a twenty-four hours ‘s Bankss have developed many other activities other than merely imparting money. Residential mortgage loaning and in term sedimentations were provided by trust and loan establishments.bulk of assets within this sector of the fiscal Industry were incorporated and supervised by federal ordinances but some companies operate under provincial charters. All are capable to assorted provincial licensing demands. These establishments moved sharply into consumer loaning and certain types of commercial loans in the 1980s. Fiduciary services were merely permitted to be offered by the trust companies.

Canadian Bankss

The Bankss in Canada are by and large referred to in two classs:

1 ) The five big national Bankss.

2 ) Smaller Bankss, 2nd grade banksA

The five largest Bankss in Canada are:

Royal Bank of Canada-Royal bank of Canada was founded in the twelvemonth 1864 and was called the Scotia. Its caput office was in Toronto, Ontario.

Toronto Dominion Bank-Toronto Dominion Bank was formed in 1955 ; Bank of Toronto 1857 ; Dominion Bank 1869.Its caput office was in Toronto Ontario.

Bank of Nova Scotia-Bank of Nova Scotia was formed in 1832 -A Scotia. Its caput office was in Toronto Ontario.

Bank of Montreal-Bank of Montreal was formed in 1817 -A Montreal, Quebec with its caput office in Toronto Ontario.

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce-Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce was formed in 1961 ; 1867A Canadian Bank of CommerceA 1867 and 1875A Imperial Bank of CanadaA – with it head office in Toronto, Ontario.

The smaller Bankss or the 2nd tier Bankss include theA National Bank of Canada, theA Desjardins GroupA ( technically non a bank but an confederation ofA recognition brotherhoods ) , A HSBC Bank Canada, andA ING Bank of Canada. These 2nd grade organisations are mostly Canadian domestic banking organisations. Insurance companies in Canada have besides created deposit-taking bank subordinates. Most of the 2nd tier Bankss are domestic organisations.

Banking Regulations in Canada

Canada ‘s federal authorities has sole legal power for Bankss harmonizing to theA Canadian Constitution, specifically Section 91 ( 15 ) ofA The Constitution Act, 1867A ( 30 & A ; 31 Victoria, c.3 ( UK ) ) , once known as theA British North America Act, 1867. Meanwhile, recognition brotherhoods securities traders and common financess are mostly regulated by provincial authoritiess.

The bank act is the chief federal legislative act for ordinance of Bankss in Canada, where Schedules I, II and III of this Act list all Bankss permitted to run in Canada under these three distinguishable classs:

Agenda I: Banks allowed accepting sedimentations and which are NOT subordinates of a foreign bank. Examples include “ The Big Five ” Bankss ( as mentioned above ) and smaller second tier Bankss such asA National Bank of Canada, A Laurentian Bank of CanadaA andA Canadian Western Bank. Because the Agenda I Bankss are non subordinates of any foreign bank, they are the true domestic Bankss and are the lone Bankss allowed to have, keep and implement a specialA security interestA described and provided for under theA Bank ActA and known to Canadian attorneies and bankers as the “ Bank Act security ” .

Agenda Two: Banks allowed accepting sedimentations and which are subordinates of a foreign bank. Examples includeA P.C Financial, A AMEX Bank of Canada, A Citibank Canada, A HSBC Bank Canada, A ING Bank of CanadaA andA Wal-Mart Canada Bank. Like the Agenda I Bankss, the Schedule II Bankss are incorporated under theA Bank Act.

Agenda III: Foreign Bankss permitted to transport on concern in Canada. Examples includeA Bank of America, A Capital One, A Credit SuisseA andA Deutsche Bank AG. Unlike the Agenda I and Schedule II Bankss, the Schedule III Bankss are NOT incorporated under theA Bank ActA and they operate in Canada, normally within the state ‘s largest metropoliss ( beingA Toronto, A MontrealA andA Vancouver ) , under certain limitations mentioned in theA Act.

Banking in USA

In theA United States, A bankingA is regulated by both the federal and province authoritiess.

Federal Reserve System

Founded by the Congress in 1913 The Federal Reserve System is the cardinal bank of the United States. It provides the state with a safer, more flexible, and more stable pecuniary and fiscal system. Over the old ages, its function in banking and the economic system has expanded. Today, the Federal Reserve ‘s responsibilities fall into four general countries:

It forms the pecuniary policy by taking into consideration the pecuniary and recognition conditions of the economic system. It helps in bring forthing employment, stabilizes monetary values and regulates involvement rates.

It supervises and regulates banking establishments to guarantee the safety and soundness of the state ‘s banking and fiscal system and to protect the recognition rights of consumers ;

It forward sees systematic hazard which may originate in the economic system and maintains stableness in the fiscal system. It provides fiscal services to assorted fiscal establishments, the U.S. authorities, and foreign official establishments, helps in modulating the balance of payment system.

It helps other fiscal organic structures and extends support to them in their operations.

History of US Banking System

The First Banks: 1791 to 1832

A cardinal bank was formed in 1791 under the first Secretary of Treasury, Alexander Hamilton. In the past the bank organisers had to get particular permission to run. But the first bank lasted till merely 1811, after which a 2nd bank of US was created in 1816which operated boulder clay 1832The metropolis bankers would prefer to do short term loans and they would supply loans after cognizing the capableness of the individual to pay off loans. Thirty to sixty yearss was the norm. After that sale they would pay off the bank loan. The banking system tended to be more broad in less developed countries ; it was easy to obtain bank loans. The husbandmans could easy obtain loans from these Bankss and pay back whenever the cargo of farm merchandises would take topographic point

Many Kinds of Money: 1832 to 1864

State authoritiess took over the occupation of oversing Bankss with the 2nd bank traveling out of concern that was the clip when bank notes came into being. These bank notes were supposed to be exchangeable, on demand, to hard currency. Unfortunately these bank notes did non turn out satisfactory. By 1860 more than 10,000 different bank notes circulated throughout the state. This resulted in huge confusion Hundreds of Bankss failed. This resulted in demand of a unvarying currency which would be acceptable anyplace in the state President Lincoln signed a alteration of that jurisprudence ; the National Bank Act in 1863These Torahs established a new system of national Bankss and assigned a accountant. Comptroller ‘s occupation was to form and oversee the new banking system through ordinances and periodic scrutinies.

Making a National Currency: 1865 to 1914

The new system worked good. National bank notes were issued by having US authorities securities notes came into circulation The confusion which existed earlier was now resolved. National bank notes were produced and distributed through an involved process..The basic printing was done and the notes were entered on to the books and bit by bit passed on to the exchequer section where the seal was stamped Next, the notes were shipped to the bank whose name appeared on them, where they were signed by two senior bank officers. The notes were so ready for circulation.

The Banking Crisis: 1929 to 1933

The world-wide depression in 1929 brought about a catastrophe for the banking system. It brought about terror in the whole economic system. Most of the Bankss failed by the last one-fourth of 1931.The banking crisis was the first order of concern for President Franklin D. Roosevelt declared a bank vacation, shuting all the state ‘s Bankss until they could be examined and either be allowed to reopen or be subjected to orderly settlement. The majority of this work fell to the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency ( OCC ) .In June 1933, Congress enacted federal sedimentation insurance. Other Torahs were passed modulating bank activities and competition, with the aim of restricting hazards to Bankss and reassuring the populace that Bankss were, and would stay, safe and sound.

A Revolution in Banking: 1970s to Today

In the new epoch, banking has come a long manner. There are all modern and advanced techniques of operation Telephone banking, debit and recognition cards, and automatic Teller machines are platitude, and electronic money and banking are germinating. Though the instruments of banking have changed, the basic mission remains the same as in the yearss of Lincoln: to guarantee a safe, sound, and competitory national banking system that supports the citizens, communities, and economic system of the United States.

As mentioned above the cardinal banking in USA has come through many ups and downs, and has evolved overtime, a shared motive throughout this history is besides apparent-to better function commercialism and authorities. This exclusive intent of banking does stay the same ne’er the less the economic crunches which have been experiences overtime.

Commercial Banking in the U.S. versus Canada

If non seen really circumstantially the banking system in Canada and USA seem to be really similar, but it is non so, there are important differences between the banking systems of the two states. The U.S. system is alone in the universe, particularly with regard to the sheer figure of fiscal establishments and its high usage of cheques, The U.S banking system is know in the universe when it comes to the figure of fiscal establishment and its high circulation of money through many instruments. But Canada seems to follow the more general state theoretical account. In add-on, U.S. companies tend to hold multiple bank relationships for both recognition and non-credit services, while Canadian companies typically have merely one, primary commercial bank relationship The federal Reserve holds a really of import function in the U.S banking system but in Canada it is handled by an association.

Chiefly the cardinal map of commercial banking is to accept sedimentations, makes concern loans, and offers related services. Commercial Bankss besides allow for a assortment of sedimentation histories, such as checking, nest eggs, and clip sedimentation. While commercial Bankss offer services to persons, they are chiefly concerned with having sedimentations and imparting to concerns.

The U.S. Banking Environment Vis a Vis the Canadian Banking Environment

There go on to be a big figure of depository fiscal establishments in the U.S. Where else the Canadian banking environment is less complicated. There are a little figure of big Bankss that branch across the full state and a company will typically hold merely one primary banking relationship, instead than the many we observe here in the U.S.

Another cardinal differentiation of the U.S. banking market is the deficiency of full countrywide ramification for commercial Bankss. It is surprising to cognize that there is non a individual bank which has its subdivision in all the 50 provinces. Because of which it has a important impact on big retail merchants which must roll up and lodge financess from one topographic point to another. Where else in Canada, the depositary establishments or Bankss are divided into three classs: Agenda I, II, or III. Agenda I Bankss are Canadian-owned and are authorized to accept sedimentations and carry on a scope of activities. The other types of banking establishments in Canada include 25-plus Schedule II Bankss, which are subordinates of foreign Bankss authorized to accept sedimentations and supply a scope of services, and about 20 Agenda III Bankss that are subdivisions of foreign Bankss with restrictions on their activities. Canada has smaller Bankss as compared to the US but the presence is more widespread as compared to the US

The primary mechanism for commercial invoicing and payment in the U.S. is still a mail-and-check-based system. Few illustrations of these are ATM Cards which consist of recognition and debit card, automatic wiring of money, ACH. The utilizations of the different payment methods are besides significantly different in Canada than in the U. S. While the cheque is still the primary business-to-business payment mechanism in the U.S. , Canadian companies have moved much more rapidly to electronic payments.

In the U.S. the nature and deepness of the relationship between client and bank is impacted by both ordinances and concern pattern. For illustration, it is still against current Federal Reserve ordinances for Bankss to pay involvement on corporate checking histories or for Bankss to offer histories denominated in currencies other than the dollar ( known as foreign currency histories ) . This means an American, if wants to keep a foreign currency must keep outside the states account. Canadian banking clients besides have the ability to open histories in currencies other than the Canadian dollar, which are known as foreign currency histories.

Due to the big figure of Bankss and other depositary establishments in the U.S. , the procedure of uncluttering cheques can be slightly cumbrous. Even though it is extremely automated, it still by and large takes one to three concern yearss to “ clear ” a cheque for a commercial client. The procedure involves the bank where the cheque is foremost deposited directing the cheque through the glade system back to the bank where the cheque was written. If there are financess available to pay the cheque, so value is sent to the lodging bank. A As mentioned earlier, there are reasonably rigorous loaning bounds imposed on U.S. Bankss, particularly those with national charters, to cut down the exposure the bank has to any one client. This frequently consequences in multi-bank recognition understandings for big U.S. companies. In Canada the regulations are more flexible ( based on “ prudent loaning patterns ” ) and the comparatively larger size of the banks-compared to both the mean Canadian company and overall economy-mean that many corporate clients do non necessitate to follow the same multi-bank adoption patterns as their U.S. opposite numbers

The last cardinal factor in the U.S. banking environment is the function played by the Federal Reserve in the direction of the payment system. In other states most cardinal Bankss “ outsource ” the operation and the direction of the payment systems ( both paper and electronic ) to the Bankss runing in that state. Central bank in Canada ( the Bank of Canada ) involves itself in the daily activities of the hired Bankss. While the functions of supervising and “ loaner of last resort ” are similar to those of the Federal Reserve, the Bank of Canada does non take part in the operation of the payments system.

Bank Regulation

In Canada, all of the Bankss are federally incorporated, via the Bank Act. “ Sunset ” clause, is imposed on the bank act which means all financially-related statute law must be reviewed from clip to clip. Changes in Canada ‘s fiscal statute law are attributed to the submergence of foreign Bankss into the state ‘s fiscal market. Besides, Canadian Bankss expanded into different fiscal services in the last one-fourth of the twentieth century ; these services include trustA businessA and insurance underwriting. While Canadian Bankss are chiefly controlled by the federal authorities

U.S. Bankss have a dual-system, where both province authorities and the federal authorities take attention of the system. A Under the double banking system, federal jurisprudence and criterions modulate the national Bankss, and supervised by a federal bureau. State Bankss are chartered and regulated under province Torahs and criterions, which includes supervising by a province supervisor.

Performance Ratios

Performance ratio is a step by which the Bankss end product or its capableness is found out. It helps in happening out conditions of non the bank is decently presenting the services it clients are anticipating out from an investing. Where the client ‘s investing is termed as input and Bankss bringing as end product. Expense ratio and productiveness ratio are two sub ratios derived from public presentation ratio. Due to its increasing engagement in fiscal services the Canadian Bankss ratio has well risen over US Bankss. Besides, Canadian Bankss pay their bank employees more than U.S. Bankss, in footings of wage and benefits. Productivity ratios is the specific scrutiny of how much end product is produced per hr

The United States tracks their Bankss ‘ productiveness ratios by utilizing a quality index created by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. This index tracks the overall sum of banking minutess within a twelvemonth.

Meanwhile, Canadian Bankss are capable to productiveness ratio scrutiny by deflating the nominal bank end product step by the state ‘s consumer monetary value

Industry Structure

The industry construction differences in the U.S. and Canadian banking systems relate to how big of a presence the Bankss have in the fiscal sectors of their several states.

In Canada, the five largest Bankss maintain 90 per centum of the state ‘s entire bank assets, while the five largest U.S. Bankss have less than 30 per centum of the state ‘s entire bank assets. Besides, the sum of Bankss in Canada increased during the twentieth century, with the allowance of foreign Bankss into the state ‘s fiscal market

the figure United States Bankss, nevertheless, decreased from 14,000 Bankss in the 1920s to 8,000 in 2005. By and large the Bankss in U.s are larger in size than that of Canada, but the figure of Bankss in Canda is more broad spread than U.S

Check Float

The clip it takes for a cheque to clear is known as float and float will detain the handiness of deposits.A Check float is a primary illustration of an inefficiency of the U.S. banking system.A Typically, cheques in the Canadian banking system are cleared outright via a national electronic glade system – doing financess available immediately.A In contrast, cheques deposited in U.S. Bankss may take up to three yearss or longer to unclutter through a manual cheque uncluttering system.A A

Difference between loaning criterions of the two banking systems

In Canada loaning criterions are much stricter and Bankss are non as advanced and aggressive as their equals south of the boundary line but execute their chief map as sedimentation takers and lodging loan suppliers. American Bankss on the other manus, have deviated from their primary maps over the old ages in order to bring forth higher above-average returns twelvemonth after twelvemonth. Relaxation of ordinances by the authorities and making favourable environment advancing place ownership by all added fuel to the fire.

Following are few of the differences

Deposit-taking hold bulk of outstanding mortgages in Canada whereas in US sedimentation taking clasp merely some of outstanding mortgages ( 30 % at terminal of 2007 )

Mortgage securitization non really permeant ( merely 29 % securitized ) in Canada whereas in the US Mortgage securitization is really permeant ( about 60 % securitized )

Majority of the MBSs issued are guaranteed by government-owned Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation ( CMHC ) whereas in the US this is non the instance

Most mortgage insurance is underwritten by CMHC ( 70 % ) in Canada whereas in the US Most mortgage insurance is underwritten by private insurance company

Mortgage Insurance covers the full loan sum in Canada whereas in the US Mortgage Insurance covers sums that exceed a certain LTV ratio ( e.g. 20 % on a 80 % ceiling )

Entire mortgage insurance is paid upfront by the borrower in Canada where as in the US Part of mortgage insurance is paid upfront by the loaner and some paid monthly by the borrower

Mortgage insurance can non be cancelled in Canada whereas in the US Mortgage Insurance can be cancelled one time the LTV drops thru a ceiling e.g. 80 %

Mortgages are five-year fixed rate loans amortized over 25 old ages reflecting the conservative recognition civilization in Canada whereas in the US Most mortgages are 30-years and have fixed-long term rates

Upfront costs for mortgages are lower in Canada whereas in the US Upfront costs for mortgages are higher

Origin fees does non be whereas in the US Origination fees are high

Few difference between fiscal coverage of US Bankss and Canadian Banks

Comparative anterior twelvemonth fiscal statements -In instance of IFRS 1 twelvemonth comparative statement is required where as in US GAAP 3 twelvemonth comparative statement is required.

Reporting ‘comprehensive income ‘ -A expansive sum of ‘comprehensive income ‘ is permitted but non required. In instance of US GAAP it must show expansive sum of ‘comprehensive income ‘ .

Categorization of liabilities on refinancing -Liabilities are noncurrent if refinancing is complete before b/s day of the month

In instance of US accounting system Noncurrent if refinancing is completed before day of the month of issue of the fiscal statements.

Extraordinary points are prohibited in instance of IFRS. In instance of US Extraordinary points are permitted but restricted.

In instance of IFRS the cost of spoilage and idle capacity can non be put in stock list but in instance of US GAAP it is non prohibited

Inventory cost -In instance of IFRS LIFO is non used for stock list cost, and in the instance of US GAAP LIFO is used for finding stock list cost.

Overdraft in hard currency are included if they form an built-in portion an entity hard currency direction where in US GAAP they are excluded.


Both US and Canada are neighbours and their economic systems are highly similar because of the fact that both are developed state.

However due many other factors such as the size of the state, its population, geographics, production and authorities policies they

edge to be few differences. Because of these differences arise a alteration in the banking policies and system which may turn out to be

beneficial at clip. In the above paper a brief comparing of both states banking system has been explained.With particular focal point

on its ordinances and fiscal ends.